In 2000, readers of ''Total Film'' magazine voted ''Withnail and I'' the 3rd greatest comedy film of all time. In 2004 the same magazine named it the 13th greatest British film of all time. Withnail & I was 38th in Channel 4's 100 Greatest Films poll.
Plot
The film details the lives and misadventures of two 'resting' (struggling and unemployed) actors in 1969, the flamboyant and alcoholic Withnail (Grant) and '...& I' (or Marwood, played by McGann), his more level-headed and worrisome friend and the movie's narrator, who are confined to a shambolic and filthy Georgian flat in Camden Town owing to their financial difficulties. Ailing and seemingly perpetually unemployed, the two decide to take a recuperative holiday to the countryside in order to gather themselves, and thus secure the loan of a country cottage belonging to Withnail's Uncle Monty (Griffiths) in order to do so.
Unfortunately, the holiday doesn't quite go according to plan; the run-down and filthy cottage is little better than the flat they've just left, the weather is awful, they have no food or supplies and the locals are surly and unwelcoming - in particular a threatening poacher, Jake (Michael Elphick) whom Withnail manages to get on the wrong side of. And as if that wasn't enough, Uncle Monty himself makes a surprise appearance, apparently with amorous intentions towards Marwood.
Production details
The film cost £1.1 million to make. Bruce Robinson received £1 for the script and £80,000 to direct it - £30,000 of which he reinvested into the film to shoot scenes (such as the journeys to and from Penrith) that HandMade Films wouldn't fund.Owen, Alistair: "Smoking in Bed. Conversations with Bruce Robinson", page 108-109. Bloomsbury, 2000.Paul McGann was Robinson's first choice for Marwood, but he was fired during rehearsals because Robinson decided McGann's Liverpool accent was wrong for the character. Several other actors read for the role but McGann eventually persuaded Robinson to re-audition him, promising to affect a Home Counties accent. He quickly won back the part.Owen, Alistair: "Smoking in Bed. Conversations with Bruce Robinson", page 109. Bloomsbury, 2000.
The period setting of this film in 1969 is consistent, apart from Marwood packing a visibly late 1980s Penguin Classic in the penultimate scene. A much closer viewing, perhaps using the pause function of a DVD player, reveals several other, less obvious, anachronisms: in the first driving scene cars from the 1980s can be seen in the background, blue motorway signs dating from well after the sixties are also visible, including a sign clearly showing "M25" (this motorway was not opened until 1986), while barcodes can be spotted on cans in the kitchen. A possible reason for such inaccuracies is the film's low budget.
Background
The narrative is told in the first person by the character played by Paul McGann, named just once in passing in the film as Marwood - and only credited as "... & I".Robinson's script is largely autobiographical. ''Marwood'' is Robinson; ''Withnail'' is based on a friend he shared a Camden house with - Vivian MacKerrell - who died young; and ''Uncle Monty'' is loosely based on the unwanted attentions he received from an amorous Franco Zeffirelli when he was a young actor http://www.withnail-and-i.com/features.php?feature=2. He lived in the impoverished conditions seen in the film and wore plastic bags as wellington boots. Robinson threw four or five years of his real life into the script, condensing them into two weeks.
In many ways, the film is melancholy and deals with endings: the end of Withnail and Marwood's friendship; the end of the 1960s (the film begins with King Curtis performing "A Whiter Shade of Pale" - King Curtis was murdered in August 1971; Danny's speech about selling hippie wigs in Woolworths); the probable 'beginning of the end' for Withnail/MacKerrell as he delivers a speech from Hamlet to a pack of wolves, the film is in part set amidst the demolition of parts of Camden at the beginning of the film. In Withnail and I, there is a strong sense that the characters fear change: from Withnail clinging to Marwood until the very end, to Danny mourning the passing of the decade, to Uncle Monty pining for the pleasures of his lost youth and cursing his old age. The characters fear change and the dangers of uncertainty that this new change will bring; but deep down, accepting that change is inevitable. The film marks the end/passing of a 'golden age.' At one point, towards the end of the film, Withnail says 'There's always time for a drink' to which Marwood quickly and bluntly replies ' No, I don't have the time.' Marwood is not merely telling Withnail that he doesn't have time for a drink; but rather, he no longer has time for ''him''. Whereas before, Marwood always had time for a drink (as is evident throughout the film) this is no longer the case. In refusing to drink with him, Marwood is implicitly telling Withnail that their time together is over; their friendship has come to an end.
"I"'s name
Despite the first name of 'I' not being stated anywhere in the film (nor surname), it is widely believed that the character's first name is 'Peter'. This rumour comes from the memorable occasion that Monty meets the two actors, Withnail asks him if he would like a drink. In his reply, Monty both accepts his offer and says "...you must tell me all the news, I haven't seen you since you finished your last film". While pouring another drink, and downing his own, Withnail replies that he has been "Rather busy uncle. TV and stuff". Then pointing at McGann he says "He's just had an audition for rep". Some fans hear this line as "''Peter'''s had an audition for rep" although DVD subtitles, the original shooting script and all commercially published versions of the script read "he's".There is however one moment when the name of "I" as "Marwood" is revealed, although not stated. When a telegram arrives at Crow Crag, the name "Marwood" is written on the envelope and is visible, upside-down, for a fraction of a second before the envelope for "I" being opened.
DVD
There are two DVD versions of the film available in Britain. One is a cheaper version, which is exactly the same as the original 1987 version, the other, a more expensive version, which has vastly enhanced picture and sound quality, as well as extras, such as a documentary. The latter is distinguished by the 'special features' section on the back of the DVD case.The film has also been released on DVD in the United States as part of the highly-regarded Criterion Collection.
Soundtrack
The soundtrack for Withnail & I, while out of print now, was available on Silva Screen Records, Silva House, 261 Royal College Street, London NW1 9LU, England.<!-- It is claimed that the soundtrack album was discontinued and deleted by the distributors because of the actions of the estate of Jimi Hendrix whose tracks are featured in the film. The family will not allow any of his music to be used to glorify or promote the use or abuse of drink or drugs. This has made the original soundtrack on vinyl valuable due to its limited availability, and even the original CD is scarce and commands an inflated price. -->
<!-- Source needed for this claim, as otherwise it reads as an attempt to talk up the resale value. -->
The film also features a rare appearance by a recording by The Beatles, whose song "While My Guitar Gently Weeps" briefly plays as Marwood and Withnail return from Crow Crag. Although the surviving members of the group rarely licensed the use of their original recordings for feature films (cover versions were often substituted, as in the case of ''The Royal Tenenbaums'' and ''I Am Sam''), George Harrison happened to be one of the film's producers, and allowed its inclusion in ''Withnail & I''.
Trivia
*After eating the potatoes which Withnail digs up, Marwood can be seen reading a book ominously titled 'Journey's End.' Whilst this can be interpreted as a sign of things to come for the pair, it also shares certain elements with the film itself: one of the characters is an unreliable alcoholic who comes into conflict with a friend and one of the characters dies, leaving the other to face the rest of the war by themselves. In much the same way, it could be said that Marwood is leaving Withnail to face the rest of his life by himself.*During the filming of the scene in which the lighter fluid is consumed, Bruce Robinson changed the contents of the can, which had been filled with water, to vinegar. While the vomiting is scripted, the facial expression is purely natural.
*A scene which never made the final cut involved Marwood and Withnail fencing. Marwood was the eventual winner.
*Bruce Robinson has said that there are two lines in the script which had to be perfect. If the actors got them as he imagined then the film as a whole would work. One is the Policeman shouting "Get in the back of the van!"; the other is Withnail saying "Fork it!" The first time Grant did it Robinson began to roar with approval but Grant could never match the first take so the scene in the film is the first take but the rest of the scene is cut to cover the director's outburst.
*The film is an adaptation of an unpublished novel written by Robinson in the winter of 1969. It was adapted into a screenplay in the early 80s and finally shot in 1986. The end of the novel saw Withnail committing suicide by pouring a bottle of wine into the barrel of Monty's gun and then pulling the trigger as he drank from it. Robinson changed the end as he believed it was "too dark".Owen, Alistair: "Smoking in Bed. Conversations with Bruce Robinson", page 128. Bloomsbury 2000
*Early in the film, Withnail reads from an article headlined "Boy Lands Plum Role For Top Italian Director" and then goes on to imply that the director is sexually abusing the boy. This is a possible reference to the sexual abuse that Robinson alleges he suffered at the hands of Italian director Franco Zeffirelli when, as a young man, he won the role of Benvolio in Romeo and Juliet. Also, Monty's full name, Montague Withnail, may refer to the fictional Montague clan in Romeo and Juliet, which Robinson's character in the film version is allied to.
*Ralph Brown appears in ''Wayne's World 2'', playing a veteran roadie called Del Preston - and turns in a performance that's strikingly similar to his portrayal of Danny in Withnail & I. In 2006 an advertising campaign for the Playmonday.com lottery was run also featuring a character clearly designed to sound and speak in the same style as Danny.
*There is a drinking game associated with ''Withnail & I'', popular amongst fans. The game consists of keeping up, drink for drink, with each and every alcoholic (and other) substance consumed by Withnail and Marwood over the course of the film. Most players may simply drink their beverage of choice regardless of what the characters consume, though this is viewed by the more "hardcore" ''Withnail & I'' fans as an "easy way out." All told, Withnail is shown drinking roughly 9½ glasses of red wine, half a pint of cider, 1 shot of lighter fluid (vinegar or overproof rum are recommended substitutes), 2½ shots of gin, 6 glasses of sherry, 13 glasses of whisky and half a pint of ale. Since the whisky alone would be more than enough to necessitate a trip to hospital for most people, few, if any, keep pace for the entire film.
Locations
* The "King Henry pub" and the "Penrith Tea Rooms" are not actually in Penrith, but in Stony Stratford, Milton Keynes (the "Crown Inn" and "Cox and Robinsons Chemists" on Market Square).* The real Penrith is shown very briefly, but most of the filming locations were actually in and around nearby Shap and Bampton.
* Crow Crag, as it was called in the film, is actually Sleddale Hall, located near the Wet Sleddale Reservoir in Cumbria. Recent photos of the location can be found at the BBC Cumbria pages. The bridge where Withnail shoots for fish with a shotgun is located at the bottom of the hill below Sleddale Hall, just a quarter mile away.
* "The Mother Black Cap" 41 Tavistock Crescent, London W11 1AD (previously the original "Frog & Firkin" and "Babushka")
Cast
* Withnail - Richard E. Grant* Marwood - Paul McGann
* Monty - Richard Griffiths
* Danny - Ralph Brown
* Jake - Michael Elphick
* Irishman - Daragh O'Malley
* Isaac Parkin - Michael Wardle
* Mrs Parkin - Una Brandon-Jones
* The General (pub landlord) - Noel Johnson
* Miss Blennerhasset - Irene Sutcliffe
* Boiler (cake shop owner) - Llewellyn Rees
* Policeman - Robert Oates
* Policeman - Anthony Wise
* Presuming Ed - Eddie Tagoe
See also
*Sherry*Camberwell carrot
*Mauve
*Garlic
*Rosemary
*Salt
*Aspirin
References
External links
* Full script
* Fan site
* The Withnail and I Fanlisting
* Withnail's Famous Coat Is Auctioned - The Guardian Newspaper
* Criterion Collection essay by Bruce Robinson
* Image gallery on BBC Cumbria
* Useful page with help on finding the elusive Soundtrack album from Withnail and I
